76 SOCIAL SCIENTIST Struggle: An Answer to Critics", Latin American Perspectives, Vol 1, No 1, 1974; C Kay, "Comparative Development of the European Manorial System and the Latin American Hacienda System", Journal of Peasant Studies, October 1974; andB Bradby, "The Destruction of Natural Economy in Peru", Economy and Society, May 1975. 7 All the following references are to various issues of the Economic and Political Weekly: U Patnaik, "Capitalist Development in Agriculture: A Note", 25 September 1971; P Chattopadhyay, "Onv the Question of the Mode of Production in Indian Agr'culture: A Preliminary Note", 25 March 1972; also see 30 September 1972 and 30 December 1972; J Banaji, "For a Theory of Colonial Modes of Production", 23 December 1972; A Gunder Frank, "On Feudal Modes, Models and Methods of Escaping Capitalist Reality", 6 January 1973; Hamza AlavJ, "India and the Colonial Mode of Production", August 1975; R Sau, "On the Essence and Manifestation of Capitalism in Ind.an Agriculture", 31 March 1973. 8 Barber, op cit, p 162. 9 H Fleischer, Marxism and History, New York, Harper Torchbooks, 1973, p 63. 10 Mao Zedong, "On Practice", Selected Works, Vol 1, p 307. n Karl Marx, "Afterword to the Second German Edition", Capital, Vol 1, Moscow, Progress Publishers, p 20. 12 Marx and Engels, "German Ideology", in On Historical Materialism, A Collection, Moscow, Progress Publishers, p 35. 13 Ibid.p 36. 14 Fleischer, op cit, p 42.