) Social Scientist Monthly Journal of the Indian School of Social Sciences VOLUME 11 APRIL NUMBER 4 (983 EDITOR CONTENTS Prabhat Patnaik EDITORIAL BOARD Editorial Note 1 M J K Thavaraj Jacob Eapen History from Below9 Kitty Menon — Sabyasachi Bhattacharya 3 Madhu Prasad Marx, Chernyshevskii and the Theory of Histo-EDITORIAL OFFICE rical Expediency in Social Transformation 424, vp House. — Kalyan Das Gupta 21 New Delhi-110001 Urbanisation in India: A Contrast with Western CIRCULATION AND Experience ADVERTISEMENT — Abanti Kundu 37 PBNo-116 Trivandrum-695 001 NOTES 1983-84 Budget: A Blow to the Productive Forces SUBSCRIPTION RATES - M J K Thavaraj 50 INLAND 3 years: Rs 150 The Architecture of Rural Housing: Some Issues 2 years : Rs 120 ,„ ^^ Annual : Rs 65 _ Ronii Khosia 56 (Students : Rs 50) Half-yarly : Rs 35 COMMUNICATION Single copy : Rs 6 Colonialism) Capitalism and Deforestation FOREIGN — Ramachandra Guha 61 (Annual in U S dollars) Sea Mail : 18 BOOK REVIEW (USA and Canada) : To International Working Class Movement (Other countries) : 24 —- Sukomal Sen 65 Articles, notes, communication and review express the views of the authors and not necessarily of the editors or of the Indian School of Social Sciences.