18 SOCIAL SCIENTIST 21 Marx-Engels Correspondence, op, cit, pp 293-94.* Emphasis added. 22 Teodor Shanin, The People's Will, unpublished manuscript, p S2. 23 Werke, Vol 35, p 179., 24 Teodor Shanin, Late Marx and the Russian Road, London, 1983. p 206 25 Ibid, p 214. 26 R P Koniushaya. Karl Marks i RevoHutsionnaya Rossiya, Moscow, 1975, p 354. 27 Werke, Vol 19. pp 384-85. 28 Kritika fliosofskikh predubezhdenii protiv obshchinnogo vlademya, Pol. Sob. Soch.» Vol. 5. Moscow. 1950. pp. 388-399. 29 Werke, Vol 19, p 405. 30 Ibid, p 385 Sec also pp 389 and 398 for the same observations with minor changes. 31 See Kritika^., Pol. Sob. Soch., Vol 5, especially pp 372-373 and pp 384-85. 32 Werke, Vol 19. p 397. 33 Marx-Engels Selected Correspondence, p 320. 34 Koniushaya, op cit, p 375. 35 E H Carr, Bolshevik Revolution, London. 1978. Vol II. p 389. 36 Ibid, p 390. 37 See Werke, Vol 22, pp 425-429 38 Werke, Vol IV, p 576. 39 Walicki. op cit, p 194.