Social Scientist The Tyranny of Labels Romila Thapar 3 The Antinomies ofTransnationalism Prabhat Patnaik 24 Emergency Assessments Vijay Prashad 36 Review Article: The Class Character of the 19th Century Renaissance in India E M S Namboodiripad 69 Discussion: On the Absence of Tower' in Marxist Theory Aunindyo Chakravarty 77 BOOK REVIEW 81 280-81