32 SOCIAL SCIENTIST 17 Marcuse, op.cit., p 23. 18 Marcuse, op.cit., p 19. 19 Marcuse, op.cit., p 11. 20 Marcuse, op.cit., p 12. 21 Marcuse, op.cit., p 14 (emphasis added.) 22 Marcuse, op.cit., p XII. 2< Marcuse, op.cit., pp 32-3. 24 Alasdair Maclntyre, "Herbert Marcuse; From Marxism to Pessimism", Survey, vol62,1967,p 39. 2U Ibid., p 40. 26 Particularly to be noted, TWAdorno (ed.), Spatkapitalismus oder Industrie gesellscha ft, Stuttgart 1969. 27 \v F Haug, ^Das Ganze und das Andere5, in, J Habermas (ed.), Antworten und Herbert Marcuse, Frankfurt 1968. Paul Mattick also notes, "It is not production and productivity as such which propel capitalism, but the production of profits as the accumulation of capital.''' See Paul Mattick, Critique of Marcuse, London 1972, p 14. 28 Ibid., p 53 29 This criticism links up with the philosophical critique of Maclntyre that was presented earlier. ^0 Joachim Israel, Alienation: From Marx to Modern Socialism, Boston 1971, p 176. 5n Marcuse, op.cit., p 25. a2 Everett M Kassalow, "Labour Relations and Employment Aspects after Ten Years" in Morris Philipson (ed.), Automation : Implications for the Future, New York 1962, pp 322-23.